Microsoft is bloating Windows with garbage and ads (and also, have you seen how bad Microsoft-owned sites like LinkedIn work on Firefox? Ugh!)
Apple is chasing pipe dreams and developing a large and unwieldy portfolio of products
These are not strictly web-related, but I’ll throw it here as items (7) and (8).
(7). Physical media of every type remains very much alive
(8). Streaming services are cannibalizing their own content–and therefore the very reason they were attractive to users over physical media and broadcast in the first place–for short-term gains
In my own practice, I’m moving away from cloud file storage and streaming media back to owning and controlling my own data. I am canceling every subscription service I can, and I even bought an old mp3 player to control my own music again (in addition to all of the glorious physical media I could never part with in the first place).
I’ve been cooking a post on “free” computing for a little while now, but not tonight.
Here is a simple lesson from today: assume the documentation is never complete and plan accordingly.
I lead a small team responsible for supporting, maintaining, and developing enhancements for a complex IWMS (thatâs Integrated Workplace Management System for the un-jargonated) used by the State of Florida to manage facilities. Though the state has only been using this system for about five years, it has been around for almost twenty yearsâand it shows. Every decision made by designers over the years, influenced as they have been by every passing fashion in web apps development, has left a residual mark on the system. There are some areas of the system where these marks are more apparent than others, but we run into them in unexpected ways every day. Perhaps coincidentally (but probably not) these little beauty marks are also the least documented portions of the system. Today, we encountered one while we were trying to figure out an alternative to the antiquated way this system handles data integrations through the API. The system uses a dummy user account, subject to the same password policies as the rest of the system, to update data. This means that we need to either, a.) change the system-wide password policy, which may make sense but we havenât considered doing yet; or, b.) someone needs to provide new service credentials to agents using the API on a regular basis. As always, we asked: hasnât someone else solved this problem already? Turning to the system documentation turned up no results, and this system is too niche for Google to turn up many useful results. As usual, then, we were on our own to find a workaround.
I felt a little thrill when I noticed a âService Onlyâ flag on user profile pages. Someone, somewhere must have come up with a solution for service accounts, I thought. Maybe this flag overrides some of the system security policies used to protect human user accounts from the humans who use them! If browsing the documentation by topic and searching the contents for âAPI credentialsâ and variants didnât work, at least this little flagclearly visible on the screen would be described somewhere and get us closer to an answer.
That was not the case. The âService Onlyâ flag was not described anywhere in the system documentation. Undeterred, we did what intrepid developers and admins everywhere would do in this situation: turn it on and see what happens. We fired up the test environment, created a throwaway account, and made our way to the screen where the little flag livesâonly to find that it is a read-only field. We could not turn it on.
Fine. In this no-code system, if all else fails, you can dig into the data model, form elements, and queries to understand by inference how things work. We delved into the form and data model to find â nothing. The boolean flag simply exists in a read-only state. There are no workflows attached to it and no associations leading to or from it.
Is this some sort of vestigial feature leftover from old versions to support legacy accounts? Can it be activated through some obscure menu somewhere else? Who knows? Itâs not in the documentation.
I draw a few, interrelated lessons from this.
As an administrator, never assume the system documentation will have the answer you need. In the absence of holy writ from the vendor, develop procedures to mitigate your own ignorance.
As a developer, write. better. documentation. What’s there is never enough. Sure, writing documentation may not be your job, but at some point it will be your responsibility.
If it’s your job to write documentation, go through every button on every screen. Assume you have never written enough and give this assumption some weight when you decide how much more work to do before release.
As a support provider, give users the ability to suggest improvements right in the documentation. “Contact Us” on the page isn’t enough. Users don’t want developers to cede their authority by deploying a wiki, but some of the features of a wiki should be more widespread. I think the “Talk” pages on Wikipedia are a great solution for user feedback on documentation.
Hereâs a good song to end the day. That “Walk On By” sample was all over the place back in the 90s, but this is a unique one.
Yesterday I asked Google Bard the kind of question Iâve often wanted to ask a search engine.
âImagine you are a professor preparing a graduate seminar on 18th- and 19th-Century British Gothic Literature,â I instructed the machine. âWhat materials would you place on the syllabus, including a combination of primary texts and secondary criticism and interpretation, and how would you group them?â
This is a complex question, but the solutionâas I understand itâshould just be a series of search queries in which the most appropriate results are mapped into the LLM matrix to produce the output. Because Google is the market leader in search, and Iâm not asking Bard to display its âpersonalityâ like Bing/Sydney (the âhorniestâ chatbot, as The Vergecast would have it), I thought this would be an ideal task for Bard.
Boy, was I wrong. Here is the syllabus Google Bard produced.*
On first glance, this looks like a valid, if unoriginal, syllabus. Bard has identified some representative primary texts matching the query and has chosen to present them chronologically, rather than thematically. That is a sane choice. And those texts actually exist.
Now let’s look at the secondary literature Bard wants students to grapple with. Bard has selected the following texts:
David Punter, The Gothic Imagination: A Critical History of Gothic Fiction from 1764 to the Present Day (1996)
Anne Williams, Gothic Literature (1994)
Stephen D. Gosling, Gothic Literature: A Cultural History (2000)
William Veeder, Gothic Fiction: A Critical Introduction (2005)
David Skidmore, Gothic Literature (2013)
Andrew James Smillie, Gothic Literature (2017)
“I would… group the secondary criticism and interpretation chronologically,” Bard says, “starting with Punter’s The Gothic Imagination, the first comprehensive critical history of Gothic fiction, and ending with Smillie’s Gothic Literature, the most recent critical history of the genre.” That sounds good, but none of these texts exist. Not one. Google Bard made up every one of the texts on this list, and several of the people listed there as well.
David Punter is, indeed, a scholar of gothic literature, but as far as I can tell has never produced a text entitled The Gothic Imagination: A Critical History of Gothic Fiction from 1764 to the Present Day. Anne Williams is Professor emeritus in the English department at UGA, but I cannot find an overview by Williams published in 1994 (though Art of Darkness: A Poetics of Gothic, published in 1995, sounds fascinating). I can find no gothic scholar named Stephen D. Gosling, and obviously no cultural history Gosling may have authored. William Veeder was a professor at U. Chicago but never wrote Gothic Fiction: a Critical Introduction. And so on. None of these books exist.
Make of this what you will. I don’t think Bing or ChatGPT would do much better at this task right now, but it is only a matter of time until they will be able to deliver accurate results. In the meantime, the machine is confidently hallucinating. Caveat emptor.
Of course, I did ask Bard to “imagine” it is a professor. Maybe it took me too literally and “imagined” a bunch of books that would be great for graduate students to read. Perhaps I should have told Bard it is a professor and insisted that it deliver only real results.
There’s always next time.
* To be fair, Google warned me twice that this would happen.
Technology is supposed to make things better. Lately it seems as though, almost day by day, the tools and systems that surround us are growing more complex and less useful. Here is an example.
The mobile phone on my desk at work flashes a notification about once a week. “Update Apple ID Settings,” the notification advises me, because “some account services will not be available until you sign in again.” I click continue and a new screen appears, entitled “Apple ID for your organization.” The screen instructs me to continue to a web address where I may sign in to my account. I tap the screen to activate a large blue button labeled “Continue,” and a browser page showing my workplace’s login screen appears. I enter my password–encrypted and saved on the phone, thankfully–and a new screen appears presenting me with the option to verify my identity through a phone call or a text message. I select phone call, because I am unable to receive text messages on this phone. If I did happen to select text verification, here is what would happen: the screen would change again, displaying a message over a set of floating periods indicating that the verification server is awaiting my confirmation text message. Nothing would happen, however, and I would need to begin the process again.
A moment after selecting phone verification, the phone rings. I answer and an automated voice speaks:
“This is the Microsoft sign-in verification system,” the voice says. “If you are trying to sign in, press the pound key.”
I tap the small window at the top of the screen representing the call in progress. This leads to another screen, where I must tap the “Handset” area to open a virtual representation of an old phone handset. I then tap the area of the glass screen corresponding to the pound key.
“Your sign-in was successfully verified,” the voice responds. “Good-bye.” The blazing red notification bubble will never disappear until I take this action.
The entire interaction takes less than thirty seconds. It is irritating in the moment, but the process is easy enough that I don’t have to think much about it once I get started. If I refused to do so, however, after a while the software on my phone would stop working. First, I would lose the features furthest from the core of the phone. Apps that change often–productivity apps like Excel or OneNote, for example–would be first to go, blocked by a verification server requiring the newest version to operate. Next, I might start to lose access to some of the manufacturer’s frequently-updated software, like Maps and Photos. Finally, given enough time and system updates, even the most basic features like mail and text messages, and then the phone itself, would stop working, rendering the $1,000 computer less useful than a concrete block until I completed the ritual of verification.
A while ago, I wrote that the future is local. File this quick note in the same folder.
Tonight I was trying to locate a handy graph showing trends in the construction of shopping malls in the twentieth century to supplement a travel essay I’m working on. I know I’ve seen charts, tables, timelines, and maps which show exactly what I needed, so I thought it would be trivial to find it on Google. Turns out it was easy to find secondary content describing what I wanted, but the primary sources were long gone from the internet. Here’s a great example.
In May 2014, The Washington Post ran a story about the death of American shopping malls. After the usual rambling wind-up to the ad break, the article got to the point: an animated map designed by an Arizona State grad student tracking the construction of malls across space and time in the twentieth century. “Over a century,” Post columnist Emily Badger wrote, “the animation gives a good sense of how malls crept across the map at first, then came to dominate it in the second half of the 20th century.” That is exactly what I wanted! I scrolled up and down the page, looking for a map with “dots… colored by the number of stores in each mall,” but it was nowhere to be found. I clicked a link to the source: nothing. MapStory.org appears to have gone offline sometime in the summer of 2020. Increasingly dismayed, I went back to Google and searched again. This Archinect article, published a few hours after the Post column, embedded the map directly. All that remains now is a blank box. Business Insider was a few days late to the party, but it was the same story there: a blank box where the map used to be.
As a last resort, I turned to theWayback Machine at the Internet Archive. An archived version of a web app like MapStory appears to have been is never ideal and only rarely works. Sure enough, the archived version of the mall map is just text gore. I’m afraid Sravani Vadlamani’s map is gone, and probably gone forever.
Failures
As corporations merge and downsize; as executives and product managers make changes to content retention strategies; as technical standards and fashions in code change over time; and as server upgrades, data loss, simple bit rot, and other forms of entropy accumulate; more and more of these primary sources are going to disappear. In the best-case scenario, dedicated archivists might be able to stay ahead of the chaos and preserve some majority of the information we see every day. Because the last ten years or more of the internet is largely hidden behind the walls of social media, however, the odds that this scenario will prevail are vanishingly small. We should be prepared for a much worse situation: if we don’t make a local copy of the things we see on the internet, they probably won’t be there when we come back.
As an historian, I am troubled by the potential consequences of this fragility. “Darkness” did not prevail in the so-called dark ages of the past because people were less intelligent, inventive, or ambitious than their ancestors. The “darkness” seems to have existed only in retrospect, when later generations recognized a rupture in information between one age and the next. Burning libraries is one way to cause such a rupture. Perhaps networked computers serving dynamically generated content is another. Let us hope not.
Maybe you remember what it felt like, what it sounded like, to use one of these. I remember the dusty plastic cover on the heavy phone book dangling beneath the box. I remember the slight delay between picking up the receiver and hearing the dial tone down the line. I remember the automated voice insisting on more coins in the machine. I remember the road noise, the ringing phone on the other end of the line, the throat clearing anticipation. Most of those sensations are gone, but a few of the old workhorses remain, including this battered old friend rotting away at a gas station just below the campus of Florida A&M University.
Inspired by 2600 Magazineâs longtime obsession with these beautiful, hackable old devices, I keep an eye open for them and try to grab pictures when I can.
There was no dial tone when I placed the dangling speaker to my ear and picked up the other end, but I did hear a strange clicking sound. That may have been the sound of wires striking metal, or the death rattle of the ancient and destroyed mechanism.
Maybe you remember what it felt like, what it sounded like, to use one of these. I remember the dusty plastic cover on the heavy phone book dangling beneath the box. I remember the slight delay between picking up the receiver and hearing the dial tone down the line. I remember the automated voice insisting on more coins in the machine. I remember the road noise, the ringing phone on the other end of the line, the throat clearing anticipation. Most of those sensations are gone, but a few of the old workhorses remain, including this battered old friend rotting away at a gas station just below the campus of Florida A&M University.
Inspired by 2600 Magazineâs longtime obsession with these beautiful, hackable old devices, I keep an eye open for them and try to grab pictures when I can.
There was no dial tone when I placed the dangling speaker to my ear and picked up the other end, but I did hear a strange clicking sound. That may have been the sound of wires striking metal, or the death rattle of the ancient and destroyed mechanism.
The vibe shift is the death of the unitary internet.
The vibe shift is the re-emergence of local, regional, national constellations of power and culture separate from the astroturfed greenery of the web.
The vibe shift is a return to âzines, books, movies, maybe even magazines and newspapers, because the web was once an escape from work and all the responsibilities of âreal lifeâ and now it has come to replace them.
Lately I have been leaving my phone in the car when I go places. These insidious toys entered our lives with a simple question: âwhat if I need it?â I cannot recall a single situation in the past decade when I truly needed a mobile phone. Instead I have begun to ask myself, âwhat if I donât need it?â What if a mobile surveillance and distraction device is actually the last thing I need to carry with me?
Not long after the guns of the Civil War fell cold in the 1860s, John Muir opened a notebook and inscribed his name on the frontispiece. âJohn Muir, Earth-Planet, Universe,â he wrote, situating himself as firmly as any of us may hope to do so. And then he started walking, a thousand miles or so, to the Gulf of Mexico. After setting out on the first of September 1867 on the âwildest, leafiest, and least trodden way I could find,â Muirâs excitement was palpable when he reached Florida six weeks later. âTo-day, at last, I reached Florida,â he wrote in his journal on October 15th, âthe so-called âLand of Flowersâ that I had so long waited for, wondering if after all my longing and prayers would be in vain, and I should die without a glimpse of the flowery Canaan. But here it is, at the distance of a few yards!â
A characteristic Florida view.
Muir undoubtedly walked a long way from Indianapolis to Georgia, but he cheated his way into Florida, booking overnight passage on a steamboat from Savannah to Fernandina. Perhaps thatâs why he felt so down and out after an easy half-day and night of conversation and loafing aboard the steamer Sylvan Shore. âIn visiting Florida in dreams,â he wrote, âI always came suddenly on a close forest of trees, every one in flower, and bent-down and entangled to network by luxuriant, bright-blooming vines, and over all a flood of bright sunlight. But such was not the gate by which I entered the promised land.â What he found, instead, was a tangle of marsh and swamp. A hopelessly flat vista of marsh broken only with âgroves here and there, green and unflowered.â Dropped unceremoniously on this inauspicious shore, without even breakfast to ease his way into the new world, Muir was overwhelmed. The peninsula was âso watery and vine-tied,â he reported, âthat pathless wanderings are not easily possible in any direction.â He made his way south from the gloomy coast down the railroad tracks, âgazing into the mysterious forest, Natureâs Own.â Everything was new. âIt is impossible,â he wrote of the forest along the tracks, âthe dimmest picture of plant grandeur so redundant, unfathomable.â Sometimes I feel the same way, though Iâve lived here longer than Muir had been alive when he walked down the lonely rail line trying to make sense of the place.
        I picked up Muirâs book recounting the journey a hundred and fifty years later because part of that very long walk took place in Florida, and I am filling up my own notebooks here on Earth-Planet, Universe with the starry-eyed hope that another book about Florida may one day emerge from their pages. Unlike Muir, though, I can draw on an infinite library of books, videos, field guides, and brochures to reduce the unfathomable grandeur of Muirâs nineteenth century gaze to the qualified certainty of my twenty-first century gaze. On a different shelf in my office, for example, I can pull down the Guide to the Natural Communities of Florida. I can leaf through the 81 varieties of land cover the authors have identified in the state until I find the one that Muir was likely to have found along his lonely railroad track: Mesic Hammock. âThe shrubby understory may be dense or open, tall or short,â the Guide reports, âand is typically composed of a mix of saw palmetto (Serenoa repens), American beautyberry (Callicarpa americana), American holly (Ilex opaca),â and so on. Maybe I can pull down the field guide to plants and trees, then; or, perhaps, just type their names into the Google search bar on my phone and find out just about anything we know about these thorny, prickly plants with just a few taps.
Callicarpa americana
The sort of deep botanical knowledge Google offers to any armchair naturalist today is what Muir hoped to gain as he explored the little-traveled paths of the South. He set out to find it by tramping through the vines, turning over the ground cover, taking notes, making impressions of leaves and flowers. With only hardbound botanical guides to aid his memoryâpaperback books then only existed as pamphlets and dime novels, not scientific guidesâwe can imagine the kind of notes that Muir would need to take to remember it all. Most of all, he had to know how to look, how to take in enough information about a plant shaded by drooping beautyberry branches or hidden beneath the cutting blades of a saw palmetto a few feet off of the trail to describe it later or look it up if he didnât know what it was. Muir did not have the luxury of a camera in his pocket, connected to an electric warren of machines making inferences from the collective learning of scientists and thousands of amateur naturalists to identify the plant instantly. Muir had to live with it for a while, turning it over and over in his mind until he could write it down. He had to bring some knowledge to the field with him, to know the important parts to remember. Muir had to work for it.
Iâve used apps to identify plants, and they are wonderful. You snap a picture of a flower, or a whorl of leaves, press submit, and like magic a selection of possible candidates appears. It only takes a moment more of reading and looking to positively identify the plant before your eyes. There is no need to walk the laborious path down a dichotomous keyâa series of this-or-that questions people use to identify plants and trees in the fieldâor stumble through the obscure chapters of a specialized field guide.If a naturalist today can download identifying data to their phone, and if they bring a battery backup or two into the field, the old field guide is as obsolete as the buggy whip. Problem solved, right?
The internet, and by extension our whole lives now, thrives on this promise of problems solved. The old âfixed that for youâ meme sums up the mindset, but you have to go a step beyond the memeâs use in the culture wars (the internetâs stock-in-trade, after all) to get there. If you donât know it, hereâs the culture war setup. Somebody posts an opinion you donât like on the internet. You strike words from the post, like this, and replace them with other words that you do like. Then you post the altered text in the comments of the original under the simple heading, âFTFY.â For example, if you wrote a tweet that said, âI love Twix!,â some wag might respond: âFTFY: I love Twix Reeseâs!â Though your interlocutor would be wrongâTwix is undoubtedly the superior candyâunfortunately the stakes are often much higher. For a while, FTFY was the perfect clap-back to a Trump tweet or a Reddit post. Like all things on the internet, however, FTFYâs popularity is fading away by sheer dint of use. Hereâs an example I found on Google in case you are reading this after the meme has completely disappeared.
FTFY
FTFY is a successful meme because it works on two levels. The first is merely discursive: here is an alternative point of view. If you go back and read one of the breathless essays, from before 4chan and Trump, on the democratic promise of the internet, youâll see a lot of this. The internet is a place for people to express their opinions, and isnât that good? Mark Zuckerberg still relies on this discursive level to justify Facebook. âGiving everyone a voice empowers the powerless,â he told a room full of people at Georgetown University last year, who, for some reason, did not burst into uproarious laughter, âand pushes society to be better over time.â If this were the end of communicationâI speak, you listen; you speak, I listenâthen Zuckerberg would be right and FTFY would be innocuous. The second level of meaning is why anyone uses the meme in the first place, though.
The second level is philosophical: here is a self-evidently correct point of view which shows that you are wrong and I am right. Someone using FTFY intends to point at differences of opinion and erase them at the same time. This creates a sort of nervous thrill in the reader, who revels in the shame of the erased whether they agree with them or not. It has no effect on the author beyond alienation, but the point is not to persuade anyway. It is to profit, in the social and psychological sense, by signaling one’s virtue in exchange for internet points. Rinse and repeat.
Facebook, Reddit, Twitter, and others turn shitposters’ play points into real dollars and power through the intentionally-obscured work of software algorithms. Thanks to this perverse alchemy, which converts mouse movements and button-presses into trillion-dollar fortunes, social media excels at delivering us to these impasses of opinion, where we can only point and gasp at hypocrisy for the benefit of those who agree with us. We call this free speech, but it feels like something else, like a sad video game we play on our phones in bed until we fall asleep and the screen slowly goes black. FTFY.
Software’s been Fixing That For You since the 1950s. It started off slowly, the awkward preserve of reclusive engineers, but–I don’t have to tell you this, you already know–grew in scale and intensity like a wild avalanche until now, when it holds the power, depending on which expert is holding forth, to either destroy life on the planet or usher in a new era free of death, pain, and inequity. This bestows upon software the elemental power of nuclear fission. Until recently, weâve accepted it without nearly as much hand-wringing. Is it too late?
The world-eating logic that propels softwareâs growth is “efficiency.” This is the Fix in FTFY. In his recent book, Coders, Clive Thompson describes the âprimal urge to kill inefficiencyâ that drives software developers. âNearly every [coder]â he interviewed for the book, Thompson writes, âfound deep, almost soulful pleasure in taking something inefficient and ratcheting it up a notch.â I understand this urge. At work I have spent the same hours I would have spent downloading and renaming files writing a script to download and rename them instead. Iâve coded macros to make it easier to populate fields on contract templates instead of confronting the banality of existence by editing Microsoft Word documents manually. As a result of this urge, coders and capitalists argue, nearly everything we do is more efficient today as a result of software than it was ten years ago. As 5G transmitters make their way to cell towers around the world, the same argument goes, nearly everything we do tomorrow will be more efficient than it is today. We accept this, the way we accept new clothes or new toys.Â
Onerous luggage
We shun or diminish the things that software displaces. Landline phones are not merely obsolete, for example. They are laughably so. The checkbook register my teachers labored for me to understand in school simply vanished some time around 2005. I left $2,000 worth of CDs sitting next to a dumpster when I moved away from my hometown in 2008 because I had ripped them all to my computer and had an iPod. (I would later deeply regret this decision). Typewriters are a cute hobby for rich actors, rather than tools so vital that Hunter S. Thompson carted his IBM Selectric II from hotel to hotel on benders for forty years. Rejecting these things feels as much like a social gesture as a personal one. Who wants to be seen writing a check at the store? Who wants to talk on a landline phone?
Shunning inefficiency strengthens our commitment to software. This brings me back to Muirâs notebook. Muir had to see, to remember, to write once in his notebook and then write again to turn those notes into something useful. Seeing and remembering, rather than taking a picture: inefficient. Looking things up in a book when he returned from the field: inefficient. Taking notes on paper: inefficient. And yet I find when I go out into the woods with my phone, tablet, or computer and do what Muir did I see very little and remember even less. I write nothing; and nothing useful, beyond a beautiful afternoon and a vague green memory, comes of it.
This is mostly my fault. I could use these powerful tools, I guess, to cash in on efficiency and make something even better. But I donât. Instead, I get distracted. I pull out my phone to take a picture and find that I have an email. I scroll Twitter for a moment, then Reddit, until I am drawn completely into the digital worlds on my screen, shifting from one screen to the next until I manage, like a drunk driver swerving back into his lane, to pull my eyes away. There is a moment of disorientation as I confront the world once again. I have to struggle to regain the revery that drove me to reach for the phone in the first place. This part is not completely my fault. The dopamine-driven design language that drives us to distraction is well known. If I manage to overcome this pattern somehow and actually take the picture, it goes to Google Photos, one of several thousand pictures in the database that I will never seriously think about again. When I take notebooks into the woods, with pen and pencil and guide book, I do remember. I see and think and make things that feel useful.
More than merely remembering what Iâve seen, working without computer vision helps me see and learn more than I did before I put pencil to paper. Because I am a historian, always looking backward, my mind turns once again to old books and ideas. I am reminded of the nineteenth-century art critic, writer, and all-around polymath John Ruskin. Ruskin understood the power of intentional sight–the practiced vision aided by the trained eye of an artist–as a key to deeper understanding. âLet two persons go out for a walk,â he wrote in one thought experiment; âthe one a good sketcher, the other having no taste of the kind.â Though walking down the same âgreen lane,â he continued, the two would see it completely differently. The non-sketcher would âsee a lane and trees; he will perceive the trees to be green, though he will think nothing about it; he will see that the sun shines, and that it has a cheerful effect, but not that the trees make the lane shady and coolâŚ.â
What of the sketcher? âHis eye is accustomed to search into the cause of beauty and penetrate the minutest parts of loveliness,â Ruskin explained. âHe looks up and observes how the showery and subdivided sunshine comes sprinkled down among the gleaming leaves overhead,â for example. There would be âa hundred varied colors, the old and gnarled woodâŚcovered with the brightness; ⌠the jewel brightness of the emerald moss; …the variegated and fantastic lichens,â and so on. This, I argue, is the vision of the unaided eye in the twenty-first century. Unencumbered by the machines that reduce our experience to arrays of data, we can see it in new and more meaningful ways.Â
In a widely anthologized tract, the renaissance artist Leon Battista Alberti wrote, “you can conceive of almost nothing so precious which is not made far richer and much more beautiful by association with painting.” I think Ruskin would have agreed. He jump-started his career through a full-throated endorsement of the Romantic master J.M.W. Turner. The artist’s deft, rapid brushwork, as seen in the detail taken from one of his paintings above, conveys the depth of painterly vision. “Indistinctness is my forte,” Turner rather famously wrote; but I see something rather more distinct than mere visual reproduction at work here. I digress.
More than a renowned art critic, Ruskin was an influential social reformer who believed that adult education, especially education in art, could relieve some of the alienation and misery suffered by workers who spent the majority of their lives operating machines. Workers in Ruskinâs era struggled for the 40-hour work week, deploying the strike, the ballot, and the bomb for the right to enjoy more of their own time. Twenty years after his death, workers throughout the industrialized world seized the time to pursue the sort of self-improvement that Ruskin longed for them to enjoy. Because we can only believe in what Milan Kundera called the âGrand Marchâ of history–that things are better today than they were yesterday, ever onward–we forget the flush of literacy, creativity, and prosperity that blossomed with the passage of the eight-hour workday. Some thirty years later, my grandfather still enjoyed the sort of self-actuated existence Ruskin advocated.
Pop managed a water filter warehouse in Jacksonville, Florida for thirty years after recovering from a gruesome leg injury he sustained in North Africa in 1944. At night, when my dad was a child, Pop took a radio repair correspondence course. He never finished high school but devoured books nonetheless, especially interested in anything he could get on Nazism. He had a doorstop copy of Shirerâs Rise and Fall of the Third Reich on his living room chair. He took subscriptions to magazines, Popular Mechanics alongside the Saturday Evening Post–nothing highbrow but dog-eared anyway–and read the newspaper religiously. There wasnât much television to watch. Father and son built models together. They went fishing.
It was not a golden time by any means. Pop was a brooding, difficult man. He kept a bottle of gin hidden in the yard. He nursed grudges and pouted over a spare dinner of Great Northern beans. He dealt silently with a gnawing pain from the war in North Africa, it seems, until he couldnât hold it in, dressing up in his army uniform one time in the depths of a quietly furious drunk and threatening to leave the family. I donât imagine he read his books and magazines when the black dog drove him to the bottle, but I hope he could take comfort in ideas nonetheless. My dad does. He chased away the lumber yard blues on Sunday night watching Nature on PBS and reading Kerouac on the side of the couch illuminated by the warm light from the kitchen. He executed masterful oil paintings on the kitchen table, weeknight after weeknight, amassing a room full of work that would make the neighbors gasp with delight at the jewel box in the back bedroom of the unassuming apartment upstairs. He passed some of this down to me, in turn, though I will never have the talent or the patience he poured into his work. I hope Pop gave that to us.
Pop was not alone in his evening pursuits, but it is hard to imagine a similar man pursuing the same interests today. In 2018 the Washington Post, interpreting survey results from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, reported that the share of Americans who read for pleasure had reached an all-time low, falling more than 30 percent since 2004. The share of adults who had not read a single book in a given year nearly tripled between 1978 and 2014. It is tempting to blame the internet and smartphones for this decline, but it began in the 1980s, according to the Post. Screens account for this change. Television, firstly and mostly, but computers, too, and now phones and tablets. I have stared at a screen for ten hours today. There is still at least two hours of screen time left before I will lovingly set my phone in its cradle by the bed and fall asleep. I am not wringing my hands over the death of books. Ours is a highly-literate era, awash in information. Drowning in text. I am wringing my hands over what seems like the dearth of deep thought, the kind of careful thinking that comes from reading without distraction, from looking without mediation, from quiet.
After a week tramping across the flat pine woods and swamps of North Florida, John Muir found himself in Cedar Key, a sleepy village on the coast which feels almost as remote today as it must have felt in the 1860s. âFor nineteen years my vision was bounded by forests,â he wrote, âbut to-day, emerging from a multitude of tropical plants, I beheld the Gulf of Mexico stretching away unbounded, except by the sky.â Then as now, however, Cedar Key was the end of the road. With no boats in the harbor and apparently little desire to move on to points further down the peninsula–and vanishingly few they would have been–Muir decided to take a job at a local sawmill and save money for passage on a timber ship bound for Galveston which was due to arrive in a couple weeks. He worked a day in the mill, but âthe next day⌠felt a strange dullness and headache while I was botanizing along the coast.â Nearly overcome with exhaustion and an overwhelming desire to eat a lemon, he stumbled back to the mill, passing out a few times along the way, where he collapsed into a malarial fever. âI had night sweats,â he wrote, âand my legs became like… clay on account of dropsy.â Uncertain whether he would even stay in town when he arrived, Muir instead spent three months convalescing in the sawmill keeperâs house at the end of the world in Cedar Key.
The fishing village a few years later.
Once he was strong enough to leave the house, the young naturalist made his faltering way down to the shore. âDuring my long stay here as a convalescent,â he recalled in the memoir, âI used to lie on my back for whole days beneath the ample arms of… great trees, listening to the winds and the birds.â I have spent long days and nights in the hospital. It is nearly impossible to imagine even a half-day in a recovery room without the option of scrolling the internet, watching TV, playing a video game. I suppose, therefore, that I am thankful for software. It fixed boredom for me.
But still, Muirâs description of Cedar Key is warm, reminiscent. It is easy to imagine that these fever days spent listening to the waves and thinking about plants and birds and life beneath the spreading Live Oak boughs on the desolate gulf coast of Florida contributed in a significant way to who he was about to become. Just a few months later, Muir was in California whooping with delight in the Yosemite Valley. It was there that he became Yosemiteâs Muir, the preservationist sage of the Sierra Club and father of modern environmentalism. But perhaps we should rename a little stretch of the quiet wooded shore in Cedar Key the Muir Woods, too. The time Muir spent there in forced meditation seems to have shaped the man, if only slightly, as the forces of wind and water in their slight but constant way shaped El Capitan. There was nothing to fix.
I have a little yellow Daisy on my front porch that Iâve been trying to keep alive for a few weeks. Iâm not doing a very good job of it. The flower lives life on a strange carnival ride of forgetfulness, swinging wildly from healthy, golden vitality to a state of near-death droopiness over the course of each week, and I feel bad for it. I feel guilty just long enough to give it another starvation ration of water from a measuring cup out of the kitchen, that is, and then forget about it for another few days. I really have no idea what Iâm doing.
I feel the same way about Twitter. Like the flower on my porch, I abandon it to time and entropy six days out of the week and overwater it on the seventh. It also gives me anxiety. I think, âI need to be better at Twitter.â I wonder, like most everyone with a high opinion of their own voice, âhow can I get more engagement?â Just last night, I fell asleep thinking about how social media is a tool that I havenât learned to properly use. Like an awl, maybe, which I also donât know how to use.Â
Unlike the flower, which needs me to live, thereâs no reason for me to feel that way about Twitter. Twitter is probably demonstrably better without me on it. But I canât help it. I fret over it, like the Tamagotchi I got in a kidâs meal from KFC in 1996 that quietly beeped its way into my psyche until I pulled the battery with a pang of guilt and a whoosh of relief two weeks later. Itâs the same mechanic: press one button to clear a need, another to build a relationship.
I need to figure out why the internet makes me feel this way.  Â