Wild Horse Nine and the Metaphysics of Irony

Even though I’ve been told that everything in a movie, every detail in every frame, is intentional, I don’t worry overmuch about goofs, bloopers, or continuity errors. I can be high-minded about art, after all, and tell myself that realism is a trap for the simple-minded. I can put on a beret and droop a Gauloise from the corner of my pouting lips and argue that realism is a conceit of the old Bourgeoisie, an illusion that seems to reduce the world in all its complexity to little miniatures that can be hung on the dining room wall or projected on a screen in a darkened room like the dancing shadows in Plato’s cave. I see no need to be uptight.

I do care, however, about people who lived in the past. I’ve spent a long time in archives and old books, and I’ve got a feel for how people who lived back there spoke, what they cared about, how they spent their time. So when Wild Horse Nine tells us these people lived in 1973, I think I know who they are. These people raised me. These people were my parents and their families, my grandparents and their friends, my teachers. These people were (are) the authors and musicians I care about. It wasn’t very long ago.

Let’s look at the main character in Wild Horse Nine. For him, it actually was quite a long time ago. Christopher Carlisle—played skillfully by John Malkovich, have no doubt—is 72 years old. He’s a veteran, we’re told, of CIA operations in Guatemala, Indonesia, Dallas, Vietnam, Ireland, and, here at the end of his career, Chile. Think about that. Carlisle would have been 45 or 46 years old when the CIA was established in 1947; 62 years old when President Kennedy was assassinated in 1963; 67 years old in the steaming jungles and thronged streets of Vietnam. When he was born, in 1901, his grandparents would have been able to tell him about living through the Civil War. He would vividly remember the first time he ever saw a Model T on the street. He would have been a young man in the early stride of his career when the stock market crashed in 1929.

In other words, Carlisle is old when we meet him in Chile. Too old to be skulking around Santiago planning the overthrow of the Allende regime. So one must ask, where did this man come from? Follow me a little further.

Too old to have been drafted into combat service when the Second World War broke out, but clearly an ice-cold operative, Carlisle was likely to have been recruited into the CIA from the Office of Naval Intelligence or pulled in following wartime service as an agent training partisans for the OSS. Let us presume, because of his role working with organized crime in Dallas in 1963, that he was an ONI officer working alongside the mafia to secure the New York docks during the war.

Carlisle would have to be a career man to be active in his forties. How did one persevere in the 1920s and 1930s Navy? Connections. Carlisle would have been an Academy man, a graduate of the class of 1923 or maybe 1924. Listen to this description of one of his classmates in the 1923 edition of the United States Naval Academy’s yearbook, the Lucky Bag:

Carlisle would have excelled in this milieu of old Annapolis buddies and their political allies to make it through the 1920s, the Depression, and World War Two. Twenty years into his career, someone deciding who to send up to the docks to get “Tough Tony” Anastasio to do his patriotic duty and rough up German spies would have had to think to himself, Chris is the man for this. And then they would have to keep thinking of him, again and again, for all the important wetwork they had in mind after the war. Thinking of him, that is, but never putting him in the office chair. Always in the field. Knees buckling, hips creaking, stiff fingers wrapped around the trigger. I don’t buy it, bub.

Try to square all that with the porkpie-hat wearing cooldude singing along to Joni Mitchell’s “Both Sides Now” and grappling with mortality on the screen, and it ventures deep into the surreal. The man says “-ish.” He looks and acts and emotes like a Baby Boomer, not a man who would have been graduating from the Naval Academy around the time Jay Gatsby was throwing lavish parties in West Egg.

I’ve gone down this long road because it leads to a giant billboard, lit up with neon lights, that screams, WHY? Why set the film in 1973? Why make it about spies? Why cast people who are 15 years too old for the roles they’re in?

Wild Horse Nine is a fantasy. Like fantasy tales, it is set in the good old days. For the writers who invented fantasy, the good old days were the time before cars and electricity stripped people of their nobility. Our good old days are a time when they had cool little cars and Top 40 Radio, but no phones to make everyone sad. Like fantasy tales, Wild Horse Nine puts us in a maze of court intrigue, knights operating according to their own brutal code of honor, tragic heroes. Its heroes are old. Their world is giving way to the new.

I can embrace this, but I cannot forgive the hackneyed postmodern irony that is mashed up like Chicken McNugget protein goo into the metaphysics of this fantasy. Administrators are sniveling junkies. 72-year-old assassins try their best to “get laid.” Wives are drunks; friends shoot each other in the head. Age is just a number. In fact, listen up: you can still, well into your seventies, make your way to remote and beautiful beaches and shoot as many people as you want.

When will the ironic mode feel as tired to film producers as it feels to me?

Leave a Reply